In early childhood education, behavior guidance strategies must balance children’s rights, emotional wellbeing, and regulatory compliance. Two commonly discussed approaches are Cool Down (Calm Down Corners) and Time Out (Isolation).
While both aim to address challenging behaviors, their alignment with ACECQA standards and Quality Area 5 of the National Quality Framework differs significantly.
Cool Down (Calm Down Corners)
-
Purpose: Designed to help children regulate emotions in a safe, supportive environment.
-
Educator Role: Adults co‑regulate by sitting with the child, naming feelings, and modeling coping strategies.
-
Impact: Builds resilience, empathy, and self‑regulation skills.
-
Compliance: Fully consistent with ACECQA’s emphasis on dignity, inclusion, and positive guidance.
Time Out (Isolation)
-
Purpose: Traditionally used as a punitive measure to stop misbehavior.
-
Educator Role: Enforcer, removing the child from group participation.
-
Impact: Can cause shame, exclusion, and hinder emotional growth.
-
Compliance: Risk of breaching National Law Section 166 (unreasonable discipline) and QA5 standards.
ACECQA Guidance
-
Children’s rights: Practices must uphold dignity and wellbeing.
-
Positive guidance: Encourages strategies that teach regulation rather than punish.
-
Cool down spaces: Recommended as supportive, non‑punitive environments.
-
Time out limitations: Exclusionary discipline is discouraged and may raise compliance concerns.
Quality Area 5 Compliance
-
Respectful interactions: Educators must foster trust and inclusion.
-
Dignity and rights: Children must never be shamed or isolated.
-
Self‑regulation support: Calm corners help children learn to manage emotions.
-
Documentation: Services should record strategies to demonstrate compliance during assessment.
Comparison Table
| Aspect | Cool Down (Calm Space) | Time Out (Isolation) |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Emotional regulation, co‑regulation, teaching coping skills | Punitive consequence, removal from group |
| Compliance | Consistent with QA5 standards (positive guidance, dignity, self‑regulation) | Risk of breaching Section 166 (unreasonable discipline) |
| Educator Role | Supportive mediator, guiding reflection | Enforcer, isolating child |
| Impact on Child | Builds resilience, empathy, and belonging | Can cause shame, exclusion, and hinder regulation skills |
| Assessment Outcome | Viewed positively by ACECQA assessors | May trigger compliance concerns during rating |
Practical Steps for Educators
-
Create calm corners with cushions, sensory tools, and visuals.
-
Model co‑regulation by guiding children through emotions.
-
Train staff on positive guidance strategies.
-
Engage families to ensure consistency between home and service.
Myth vs Fact: Cool Down vs Time Out
Myth: “Time Out is the same as Cool Down — both are just ways to manage behavior.”
Fact:
-
Cool Down = A supportive calm space where children learn emotional regulation with educator guidance.
-
Time Out = Punitive isolation that removes children from the group, risking shame and exclusion.
Myth: “Time Out is still acceptable under ACECQA standards.”
Fact:
-
ACECQA discourages exclusionary discipline.
-
QA5 requires positive guidance that upholds dignity and rights.
-
Cool Down spaces are encouraged as best practice
-
Time Out may breach compliance.
Myth: “Children learn self‑control from Time Out.”
Fact:
-
Cool Down spaces build coping skills through co‑regulation.
-
Time Out often stops behavior temporarily but doesn’t teach long‑term strategies.
Choose connection before correction. Calm corners align with ACECQA expectations, build resilience, and meet Quality Area 5 compliance. Time Out risks non‑compliance and undermines children’s rights.
In modern early childhood practice, Cool Down strategies are not only more effective for teaching emotional regulation but also align with ACECQA’s expectations and Quality Area 5 compliance. Time Out, when used as punitive isolation, risks breaching children’s rights and regulatory standards. Educators should prioritize calm spaces, co‑regulation, and documentation to ensure both best practice and compliance.
Further Reading
Calm Down Techniques For Overresponsive Children
Quiet Corners: Supporting Introverted Children in Busy Early Childhood Classrooms
Easy Calming Area Setups: Photo Inspiration For Educators
References:
Quality Area 5: Relationships with children | ACECQA
QA5 Information Sheet - Supporting Children To Regulate Their Own Behaviour | ACECQA
Working as a childcare professional can be a challenge especially when dealing with behavioural problems which may arise. The techniques we use when dealing with
There are different types of behaviour that children can display and sometimes it can be hard to manage, especially if a child is having behavioural
As Educators, there will be many instances where you will need to write about a child's behaviour. For a behaviour management plan, assessments, half-yearly or
As a parent, your behavioural expectations of your child can be higher than what is actually developmentally appropriate for your child's age.
As Educators when communicating with Parents (through verbal or non-verbal communication), there will be times where we need to discuss issues or concerns that may
Challenging Behaviour is when a child does something that hurts themselves and/or other people.
It's always difficult to bring up behavioural issues with parents, it can be nerve wrecking to tell a parent that their child misbehaves but that
As part of your child's development it is normal for your child to have anxiety and fears. A baby commonly shows a fearful sign to
All children deal with anger on a daily basis. Thinking about it as a child, there is a lot to be angry about. Elder people
It is important to understand that your child behaviour problems could not just be from attention seeking. There are many factors to take into consideration
